Some philosophies of art are based on respect for intense human feelings and originality.  Standards for judging include:

First Impression:

The work expresses a definite feeling.

Design:

• The proportion of parts, color, and other elements is unexpected or exaggerated.
• The total design is dramatic or original.  It gives you a definite feeling.

Subject/Theme:

• The subject or theme is unique, dream-like or fantastic.
• The subject or theme seems to come from the artist’s desire to communicate a strong feeling (the great joys, sorrows or problems of people).

Materials:

• The use of materials is original or unexpected.
• The materials and techniques are an important part of the mood or feeling in the work.

Functional or Decorative Art:

• The work has an unusual function or combines several functions.
• The design of the work is unexpected and causes you to react in new ways.

(source)